Wednesday, April 20, 2011
Mad Rant: Wedding Coverage
I am seriously in danger of losing my voice from shouting at the TV and I’m running out of channels to switch to. Maybe the Cartoon Network would be a safe bet, because I’m running out of options. American arrogance and hypocrisy have been on full display, more and more as the big day draws closer and it is stomach turning. I find it quite shameful as someone who is generally pro-America and ready to admit that, among the ranks of the republics of the world, the United States has done an above average job. Then something like this comes along and makes at least the presiding “talking heads” of this country, left or right, look like a bunch of simplistic, stuck-up, hateful hypocrites. Not only do they trash the excitement over the royal wedding (and I will admit the ‘celebrity’ aspect of monarchy is not my favorite aspect of the venerable institution) but they take the occasion to trash the British Royal Family and the British monarchy as a whole. Some limit themselves to simply being coarse and rude while others are downright hateful and slanderous.
For example, I have heard more than one “talking head” make the British Royal Family out to be simply a bunch of murderous war criminals or gangsters because of all the blood that has been shed “in the name of the Crown”. That is certainly rich coming from advocates for the United States. America is a nation of popular sovereignty as we all know, yet do these people consider how much blood has been shed “in the name of” the American people? By their logic we should hold the American people of today responsible for everything that has ever been done by those holding power in their name from the eradication of whole Native American populations to the mass enslavement of Africans. It hardly seems a genteel or respectful way to speak of the foundation of the government of America’s most stalwart ally and loyal friend. I tend to think that one of the reasons America has been so successful is the extent to which the USA borrowed from the British constitution in setting up the American republic. We even carried over some traditions that make no sense whatsoever in the context of this country but which we continue simply out of tradition.
One of the most hypocritical aspects of this, and sadly not a unique one, is the equality argument. They moan and groan about the coverage given to the royals because “we” are supposed to believe in equality where no one is better or more important than anyone else (as if that has ever been the case). Yet, they themselves treat the royals in a “special” way by treating them worse than everyone else. This has long been one of my biggest annoyances with republicans. They don’t think things like royalty and aristocracy are acceptable because they pass along rewards (honors, titles etc) to people who did not actually earn them themselves. Yet these same people seem to have no problem passing on guilt to people that have done nothing wrong themselves. They decry showing favor to someone just because their last name is “Windsor” and yet are blind to their own hypocrisy in showing hatred of someone just because their last name is “Windsor”. Why else all the smug condescension or outright insults toward someone like Prince William who never did any harm at all to any of these people?
Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)
IT’S the Power of Monarchy against the Power of revolution. This is why I despise the whole American Founding Mythology. Its quiet different form the reality, in which the Founding Fathers didn’t disparage Monarchy at all, and has become basically the same as the Marxist Narrative of Workers uniting and revolting against Monarchy because its Inherently Evil and needs to be torn down.ReplyDelete
It’s the corrupting influence of Republicanism and the inherent divisiveness and demand to tear anyone down that has anything that makes me see it as nothing but Satanic.
While I do not hate America, this modern Mindset of Democracy can only bring the opposite of heat it promises. Moral degradation, division to the people, and abject hatred of anything that’s seen as possibly better than Larry the Cable Guy.
Lets face it, despite what some TEA ;partiers and Glenn beck may think, Republicanism leads to Communism. It must. If you honestly believe all men were created Equal and honestly believe that there can be no Titles, you have to remove Anything that makes anyone special or Unique. Property alone makes some better off than others.
Monarchy breeds good manners, moral conduct, and strong Character. Dos it always work? No, but this is what the Ideology tends to focus on. All Republicanism can focus on is the shouts of angry mobs screaming for entitlements and demanding others be dragged down into the Mud.
Reading these mad rants it seems that you shall remain a Mad Monarchist for a long-long time. :)ReplyDelete
Oh, you're not alone. The Sydney Morning Herald has gone through and decided neither family is particularly good - the Middletons for being too bourgiouse, the Windsors for being royals.ReplyDelete
I really can't understand why they talk down an occasion of love. It doesn't matter who the rest of the family is and their various sins, what matters is the Prince and Princess-to-be.
And alas, I don't think anyone today would see that, except for an excuse to take a swipe at the monarchy. And out of sheer jealousy, no less.
I also often wonder about this whole equality thing. Are we judged by our merits (meritocracy) or our conforming to public "norms" (equality)? I know everyone here knows these are mutually exclusive concepts claimed by republicans, but perhaps it is something we need to come in and ask them at the first available opportunity.
This is a sad display. It is painfully obvious even to us Old Worlders that most Americans are fascinated by Monarchy and the British one in Particular. The news media knows this too, hence the coverage to guarantee ratings, their inane invective is capitalising on the interest in order to spread their ideology further by denigrating something ancient and precious. As they arewont to do. They are less then swine.ReplyDelete
With regards to channels, try switching to the discovery channel, if nothing else, maybe Mythbusters is on. As an avid afficinado for Animation of all kinds, I suggest not wasting your time with CN, any shows there that have any sort of appeal to those older then 12 have a nasty habit of being ruthlessly cancelled.
I have wondered the same thing Mr Wells. Here you have a happy young couple, who could possibly have anything negative to say about that? And the way some of these people go on I've asked the idiots on TV, "What happened? Did Prince William come over to New York and kick your dog or something?" I mean, what did these two ever do to you? It baffles me.ReplyDelete
Well, it doesn't matter what think a few owners of the media that hates the monarchy for some reason that we don't know, because the monarchy and all the monarchs are superiors to that richs republicans (not of the party, supporter of republican sistem), they are just jealous of not being from the nobility and because of that they haye the monarchy, no matter how much money they have they will still be just Citizens of a petty republic and the royals will still be royals.ReplyDelete
Hi from Argentina.
I had the misfortune of reading today's NY post and Andrea Peyser "article" about the royal family, looks like Murdoch strikes again.ReplyDelete
I do not understand why monarchy turns into celebrity. I don't like it. Monarchy is a not an institution to show off, but one to ruleReplyDelete